Wednesday, February 23, 2005

North Berwick, West Links review



How can you truly review one of the wonders of the golf world? That's the issue when it comes to North Berwick's West Links, undoubtedly one of the world's great golf experiences. Quirky? Yes. Remarkable? Surely.

The first issue is finding the course -- it is a hard left off the main road as you enter Berwick. If you miss it, as my car did, you'll tour right around downtown Berwick before emerging on a road back near the course. From there you park alongside a white fence -- that turns out to be right next to the 18th fairway.

The opening hole is a 328 yard par four -- as strange a hole as you are likely to ever play:

Example

The tee shot, right next to the starter's hut, is intended to land near a foot path that crosses the fairway, which is nearly as wide as the opening hole at St. Andrews. The second shot is blind, over a hill to a green perched near the sea wall. In a word - strange.

Thankfully, the second hole is world class, certainly one of the most majestic tee shots you'll ever hit.

Example

At 431 yards, this is a great par four, made more impressive by the fact you can play the ball from the packed sand on the beach if you happen to slice one there. The second shot is not easy, but if you can cut a long drive out to the left, you can still hit a mid-to-short iron in. On the sunny day the photo above was shot, I was hard pressed to think of a better hole -- anywhere.

Quirks abound at Berwick, mainly because it is another course that was molded over time, rather than built like today's modern efforts.
No where is this more evident than in the third hole, a 464-yard beast.

Example

The hole requires a long straight drive -- though the tee shot is apparently often downwind. Once there, players will find one of the walls that crosses the course -- with a narrow gap and a sign that can be seen in the photo. If you've managed to miss the fescue, players then have to navigate a long iron into a large green. Thankfully it is possible to roll the ball onto the green.

In many ways, the rest of the front nine is good, but not stunning. Holes continue to run away from the starting hole, peaking in the ninth, an interesting par five with a fascinating green site.
I found the 11th to be the next stunner, especially given its tee shot high on the dunes that run along the ocean.

Example

The 13th it one of the holes almost everyone has heard about.

Example

I've posted this photo before -- for North Americans it is quite jarring. The hole is not long -- a total of 365 yards -- but the green is protected -- by a wall.
I love the pro tip in the yardage guide: "Don't argue with the wall -- it is older than you."

The most famous hole on the course is the Redan, the 15th hole. Often thought to be one of the world's great par threes, it features a blind tee shot over bunkers to a green that falls away. It is a difficult hole, but presents many options for the inventive player. Interesting to note that one of my group made birdie by almost skulling a shot and ending up within inches of the hole.

Example

The final good hole at Berwick is the 17th, a strong 425 yard par four. It features a green site perched on the table top of a hill.

Example

If you survive the 17th, the 18th is a breeze -- a strange 274 yard par four, where the only concern is the cars parked alongside the fairway. As the guide says: "Concentrate. Car repairs are expensive."

Overall: North Berwick's West Links is one of the great experiences in golf. Though at a little more than 6,000 yards, it might not appear testing -- but all the facets are there. It forces a golfer to think in a way few modern courses do. It is hard to overpower Berwick -- which is why it still holds up over time. Architect Tom Doak, in his Confidential Guide, listed Berwick as one of his Gourmet's Choices. Hard to argue with his take on this amazing course which is a throwback to golf's beginnings.

5 Comments:

At 12:38 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

EASILY one of my favorite golf courses...that place just makes you want to play golf.
I like the first hole but not as a first hole.
2 is all-world...how about the swales on the left side of the fairway! which make you think twice about staying way clear of the beach.
Only semi-weak holes are 5 and 18, IMO...although there is a certain charm to the simplicity of 18.
I can't think of too many courses that require so many varied shots as N. Berwick does and yet it's very playable for all levels. It'll be my first tee time when I get back to Scotland one day.

 
At 12:40 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Ooops, forget to leave a commentor identity...it's Matt.

 
At 2:29 PM, Anonymous Secretary - North Berwick Golf Club said...

Enjoyed reading your comments regarding our golf course. You can find out more from our website at www.northberwickgolfclub.com where further visitor comments can be read and posted.
Visitors will be made very welcome in our clubhouse.

 
At 2:44 PM, Blogger Alan said...

I think the 16th has to be one of the unsung great hole of links golf. From memory you have out of bounds (the childrens’ course) to the right, a 4 foot high stone wall about 60 yards in front of the tee from which balls can rocket back through the group on the tee leaving the unfortunate further away than when they started, and if you clear the wall there’s a burn at about 220 yards just waiting to make your acquaintance. If you avoid all the trouble then you find yourself facing a long approach to an unusual two-section elevated green, with the pin usually on the postage stamp sized area at the back.

I believe Tom Watson sat in the adjacent Marine hotel watching qualifiers for a Muirfield Open attempting to negotiate the hole in par and when they’d finished he couldn’t resist tackling it himself with his wife as caddy. He was duly ejected from the course – no-one can play on a Qualifying day – but I think he received Life membership instead. I never heard if he got his par though.

Alan

 
At 4:23 PM, Blogger aberthoff said...

Good God, man! Looks like you played this on Scotland's annual sunny day! Seriously, North Berwick is sublime, rain or shine, windy or close. The crazy split-green (17th, is it?) with the bizarre gully is worth mentioning, as are the incredible Victorian mansions lining much of the course. I kept expecting to see Bill Wyman or Robert Plant cutting roses in the back garden.

Good post, RT.

 

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home

eXTReMe Tracker