Friday, November 11, 2005

Course review: Mystic Golf Club, Ancaster, Ontario


Course Review: Mystic Golf Club, Ancaster, Ontario
Designer: Tom Pearson
Opened: September, 2005


Gaining some sort of attention in the heavily golf saturated market of Southern Ontario is tough these days. The quality of public golf is high and the customer is savvy, sharp and knows exactly what he wants. They search out and research the places they are going to play and keep their eyes focused on local golf periodicals for new clubs that might match their interests and their pocket books.

Given this, Mystic Golf Club, about 10 minutes from Ancaster, is aptly named. Few know much about the course, which was in planning stages for more than a decade before it became a reality. And since it has had one of the most low-profile openings of any course in the area in the last few years, the public can be forgiven if they still don't know this course exists. No promotion and no advertising, plus a rural location on a sideroad with no signs typically equals no golfers. Interestingly, despite the clubs best efforts to become the Ontario Greta Garbo of the golf scene, Mystic managed 1,000 rounds in the two months since it opened.

Now that the preamble is done, here's the hard part: Is it any good? The answer is yes, though I reserve the right to make several comments about the club that run contrary to my overall impression.

Mystic Golf Club is different, which is a nice change. It has small greens, narrow fairways in spots and can be tough as nails. It is a bit of a throw back to the time when developers like Kaneff, who created Lionhead, determined they wanted to build "players' clubs" (though this is much better than either of the Lionhead courses). Courses developed for serious or talented players are almost always done badly because they exclude a majority of the public which doesn't break 90. Developers and designers too regularly misunderstand what makes a "players course," and instead create overly difficult courses that aren't a lot of fun for anyone. Thankfully, Mystic largely avoids this trap, but only just. The best difficult courses offer options -- especially off the tee. In this respect, Mystic can occasionally come across as a one-trick pony, where players are expected to hit long straight drive after long straight drive. There are other issues as well. For one, the three sets of men's tees -- 7,365; 6,713; and 6,096 yards -- are badly conceived. Too many players, afraid at being laughed at for playing the course at 6,000 yards, will step back and get badly beaten by the forced carries at 6,800 yards.

This will likely also create pace of play issues. Certainly Pearson had some difficulties in routing through the valleys and wetlands that run throughout the property but are rarely near greens or tees. Still, one would have thought he could have managed to find the money yardage of 6,400 or 6,500 yards that every other golf architect in the province seems to have managed to find. In recent years, I can only recall the much maligned The Rock in Muskoka that opened with such an odd variety of yardages.

There are a few other downsides, including the fact that several of the holes in the front and back nine, which play on lackluster land, have a back-and-forth feeling. This is especially apparent on the front nine in the 5th, 6th, and 8th holes which are challenging, but plain. The 8th is saved by a good green site a different tee shot and the first glimpses of the terrific 9th. Once past the interesting, but strange, par five 10th, and strong downhill par three 11th with its Nicklaus-style green, we hit another section of holes that play between the valleys and are a bit staid. Pearson also comes to rely on two-tier greens which can be found throughout the course and accentuate the repetitive feel. That said, the greens at Mystic Club buck the trend of recent courses constructed by the likes of Doug Carrick or Thomas McBroom given their small size. It means hitting the greens can prove problematic, but once on the putting surfaces and on the correct tier, the gentle movements make birdies quite possible. Though the course was in tough shape in places, much of which can be excused given its newness, the greens were in exceptional condition.

Much has been made about the width of the fairways at Mystic, which in places average 28 yards wide (see the photo to the left, of the sixth hole, for example), or about a third narrower than most of the new courses that have opened and focused on playability in the past decade. Interestingly, Pearson utilizes these narrow fairways to on the holes with the poorest land, perhaps a compensatory move to distract golfers from the bland parts of the course. Not surprisingly, the best parts of the course, like the bold 9th, with it bunker in the middle of the landing area, have relatively wide fairways and present players with options off the tees. The weakest parts are fairly one-dimensional, with tight fairways and inside angled bunkers.

The best portions of the course utilize the valleys and wetlands as forced carries off the tee or on approaches to the greens. Take, for example, the terrific par four 14th, with its tee shot across an expanse of marshy wetlands, to a narrow fairway that runs down a hill. The green is perched neatly against the wetlands valley, making for an interesting approach.

The finishing hole, which plays 453-yards from the tips (and can be seen in the opening shot of this review), provides one of the few instances of real drama on the course, with an extraordinary tee shot from blocks set on a the top of a hillside and looking down over more wetlands. The carry -- approximately 230 yards -- is intimidating, and if you manage to find the short grass, you still face an uphill approach to a well-bunkered green that falls away at the back.

If it were all as strong as the 18th, Mystic would prove to be one of the best courses in Canada. Instead, it is strong in places, and just average in others. Unlike the work of David Moote, Ted Baker or Rene Mulyaert, there is nothing downright awful, awkward or bad in design terms on the course. However, several facets, like the bunkering, are so straight forward as to be plain. There's nothing wrong with it -- but you'll have a tough time recalling some of the middle holes on both nines, especially since the bunkering lacks any distinctive qualities.

Even considering those factors, Mystic has enough redeeming features to make it enjoyable. However, like Bond Head, the high-end course that opened earlier this summer north of Toronto, the toughest challenge for Mystic Golf Club may be enticing players to come and tackle it given its $125 green fee that is exceptionally high for the area. Nearby Copetown Woods, which is an above-average public course within a five minute drive, offers plenty for a lot less. Mystic is good, but it will be interesting to see whether players think it is good enough to warrant the considerably higher price.

24 Comments:

At 2:00 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Mystic is a wonderful golf course and "golfers" will really enjoy its challenge and design. The par 3 third is a beauty..

 
At 8:13 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Mystic will be OK, in a year or two. The tees and greens are good, everything in between is weeds and dirt. This course should not be open, period. They should be embarassed to take $95 for the green fee (the special rate for May). One of the worst golf courses I have played in years, and I had the displeasure of going around twice. They have an all-day ticket, but not even that would make me ever consider going back.

 
At 5:20 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I played Mystic and think the comments made here are a little harsh. There were a couple of weak fairways but it is unfair to say they were all mud and weeds. Far from it. For a new course I found the conditionng very acceptable. I will go back and play it again soon. The layout and design to me are well worth the rate ($95) they are charging.

 
At 11:56 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Mystic is a golf course with a lot of potential. Opened in November 2005, the course shows its immaturity. Many fairways were somewhat barren and have yet to fill in. Water seemed to be in short supply as the course was quite hard and dry. However, on a positive note - the greens were lightning fast and ran true. Some of the best I've played in this area. The layout will be a challenge to high handicappers as long straight drives off the well manicured tee blocks are a must. There is very little in the way of facilities. The clubhouse is temporary, little more than a trailer. There is a putting green but that is about it. In summary, at $85 (including cart) Mystic proved to be an interesting track to play. This is a course with a lot of potential for the future. I enjoyed the game and look forward to playing again in a couple of years when the course has matured.

 
At 2:30 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I just played this course for the first time Oct '06 and absolutely loved it. I've heard many negative comments about it but they were all non-golf related: no clubhouse, no beverage cart, no ball washers, etc. If you want real golf, this is a great place to play. It rivals or even beats Lionhead Legends as my favourite local course, but much more affordable. I can see what the operational problems for it would be though, because you have to be a competent golfer to enjoy this course. Many visually intimidating carries (none more than about 200 yds though) off the tee would not allow your typical "corporate golfer" to enjoy himself, especially given that there is no clubhouse or beverage cart. I have to agree with the article though in that a set of tee blocks of around 6400 yards would have made sense to attract a wider range of players, and the price is steep for the area. No marketing either - I only heard about the course via word of mouth in Aug 06. I understand the course is in receivership, but I hope it sticks around because it's a course that just doesn't let up if you want to challenge your game.

 
At 5:03 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

It seems a shame that the Hamilton area cannot appreciate this type of golf course for what it is. They have a real hidden gem here. I believe better marketing to the Toronto area 'corporate' golfers would help, but don't be misleading, this is about the golf. A true test and challenging from all tee decks. Beer swilling hackers that are more interested in chatting up the cart girls need not enter. Please stick to the many courses around that are less costly. Hey, think of how much more money you'll have for beer.
For the golfers, book a time and do it quick, I too am afraid this gem may not be available to the general public for very long. But make no mistake, bring your 'A' game!

 
At 3:49 PM, Blogger A said...

I've also heard that golf clubs in Ontario are one of the best in this part of the world.

 
At 6:57 AM, Blogger brian said...

Wow, everyone seems to like the course. As I have seen in the pictures, I'm impressed with the course and I'm hoping to visit the place and play the game we love. Thanks for sharing and I'll visit try to visit there soon.

Cheers,
Brian
golf courses in Virginia

 
At 6:55 AM, Anonymous Golf Vacation Las Vegas said...

This golf club is looking amazing. I am going to experience it in person.

 
At 4:33 PM, Anonymous Buy Viagra said...

viagra online
generic viagra

 
At 4:14 AM, Blogger darrell moddy said...

Nice post. I have been searching for articles about valves and actuators and your post really helps. Thanks a lot for posting this.
payday

 
At 4:17 AM, Blogger darrell moddy said...

If you had some way of rating posts I would for sure give you a high rating my friend!
call center outsourcing

 
At 4:24 AM, Blogger darrell moddy said...

Let us know if you have any comments!
loans

 
At 4:27 AM, Blogger darrell moddy said...

Well it gives lots of knowledge about Real Estate........
I like tit & it gives directions before going to choose any Real Estate.....
call center outsourcing

 
At 4:32 AM, Blogger darrell moddy said...

If you had some way of rating posts I would for sure give you a high rating my friend!
payday loans

 
At 4:34 AM, Blogger darrell moddy said...

hi,
i just wanted to say how much i enjoy reading your blog. in a world full of spin, it's nice to get some fact-based analysis.
keep up the good work.
call center

 
At 3:25 AM, Anonymous mario games said...

Nice post! This is very informative! Great job! Kip on posting!

 
At 3:26 AM, Anonymous ragdoll games said...

I’m really impressed that threes so much about this subject that’s been uncovered and you did it so well, with so much class.

 
At 4:00 AM, Anonymous sports games said...

Very nice post. I really enjoy the article. I come here from the Google while searching for some good article. Thanks

 
At 4:01 AM, Anonymous sniper games said...

I appreciate your idea here. Definitely it has a good content. Thank you for imparting more of your own thoughts. Good job!

 
At 11:40 PM, Blogger Dylan Hall said...

Well Whattadya know, yet another great site to add to my reader! Google blog search has you pretty well indexed it seems! you have some brilliant contents!

infiniti parts

 
At 4:11 PM, Blogger deganredline said...

Yes, but can you afford the massive financial and technical outlays implicit in the iPhone studio system?

Keychains

 
At 2:04 AM, Anonymous Socialkik said...

Socialkik is the #1 place to buy cheap facebook fans, you can also buy twitter followers, youtube views and subscribers and google +1 votes. Try coupon code: STANDARDKIK for $10 off.

 
At 2:31 AM, Anonymous publishers ppc networks said...

I found my way to make money online - www.BreezeAds.com - Get on the board today and start monetizing your website

 

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home

eXTReMe Tracker